Healthcare Litigation

Mr. Stris litigates healthcare disputes throughout the country. He is also retained by medical providers, government officials, and employers to provide advice on regulatory compliance and litigation avoidance. For example:

Montanile v. Board of Trustees [Read more here]
After preserving the key legal issue through briefing and argument in the Eleventh Circuit (Eleventh Circuit Brief | Argument Audio), Mr. Stris and a team of firm lawyers persuaded the U.S. Supreme Court (Petition) to hear this important case about the scope of reimbursement rights available to federally regulated health insurance plans. In an 8-1 decision authored by Justice Thomas (Opinion), the Court adopted the position advanced in our firm’s merits briefing (Our Opening Brief | Our Reply) and argument (Audio). This was the third of three related cases handled by Mr. Stris and our firm before the Supreme Court beginning with Sereboff v. Mid Atlantic Medical Services, argued by Mr. Stris in 2005 (Audio), and followed by US Airways v. McCutchen, briefed by our firm in 2013 (McCutchen Brief).

Gobeille v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. [Read more here]
Mr. Stris was retained by the State of Vermont to assist in the preparation of a petition for certiorari (Petition) in this important healthcare preemption case. After our petition was granted, Vermont retained our firm to continue as co-counsel on the merits. After briefing (Our Opening Brief | Our Reply) and oral argument by Bridget Asay (who at the time was the Solicitor General of Vermont), the Court rejected our position. Justices Ginsburg and Kagan dissented (Opinions).

Catastrophically Injured Individual v. Health Plan Fiduciaries
Mr. Stris represented a heroin addict who was rendered quadriplegic in a terrible car accident. Insisting that the accident was not covered, our clients’ health plan refused to pay for any of the $1.3 million in medical bills resulting from the accident or to cover any future medical care. Without any need for litigation, Mr. Stris was able to persuade the health plan to do an about face and cover all relevant medical expenses (Our Administrative Letter-Brief) (redacted).

Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Montana, Inc. v. Fossen
After the Supreme Court called for the views of the United States, Mr. Stris was retained by the former Insurance Commissioner for the State of Montana to serve as lead appellate counsel in this important case about the federal preemption of state insurance law. After reviewing submissions (Our Letter Brief) and meeting with both sides, the United States recommended denial of the petition (U.S. Amicus Brief). The Court subsequently denied the petition, preserving the Ninth Circuit victory for our clients.